Dandruff Shampoo Ingredients Explained: What Works, What’s Outdated, and What’s Actually Gentle on Your Scalp

Dandruff Shampoo Ingredients Explained: What Works, What’s Outdated, and What’s Actually Gentle on Your Scalp

We’ve all been there: battling white flakes, itchy scalp, or greasy roots—only to find our shampoo makes things worse, not better. When it comes to treating dandruff effectively, the ingredient list matters more than the scent or the label.

Let’s break down the most common dandruff-fighting ingredients found in shampoos today. Some are classics that have been around for decades—but not always in a good way. Others, like Piroctone Olamine, are becoming the gold standard for modern, gentle dandruff treatment.

 

 

1. Zinc Pyrithione (ZPT) — The Classic, But Harsh Choice

Zinc Pyrithione has been a staple in drugstore dandruff shampoos since the 1960s. It works by inhibiting fungal and bacterial growth on the scalp. While it’s effective in reducing visible flakes and irritation, its long-term use can sometimes dry out the scalp or cause resistance in certain fungal strains.

Pros: Accessible, inexpensive, works fairly quickly
 Cons: Can be drying or irritating with prolonged use; not ideal for sensitive skin
 Verdict: Old-school but still commonly used

 

 

2. Ketoconazole — Strong but Prescription-Level

Originally developed as an antifungal medication, Ketoconazole is a powerful ingredient often found in prescription or clinical-grade shampoos. It aggressively fights Malassezia fungi, the main culprit behind dandruff and seborrheic dermatitis.

Pros: Very effective for severe or chronic cases
 Cons: Too harsh for everyday use; may lead to hair dryness or breakage if overused
 Verdict: Best reserved for clinical treatment, not daily maintenance

 

 

3. Salicylic Acid — The Exfoliator

Salicylic Acid works by breaking down dead skin cells and excess oil on the scalp. While it’s helpful in reducing visible flakes and unclogging hair follicles, it doesn’t treat the fungal root cause of dandruff. Overuse may also lead to dryness or increased sensitivity.

Pros: Great for scalp buildup or oily scalps
 Cons: Doesn’t stop dandruff recurrence; can cause rebound dryness
 Verdict: Best used in combination with moisturizing or antifungal ingredients

 

 

4. Coal Tar — The Outdated Heavyweight

Coal tar was once the go-to ingredient for treating scalp psoriasis and severe dandruff. It slows down the production of skin cells and reduces inflammation. However, it has a strong odor, potential toxicity concerns, and is banned in some countries due to safety regulations.

Pros: Works for thick scale buildup
 Cons: Strong smell, can discolor hair, may cause sun sensitivity
 Verdict: Outdated and rarely used in modern formulations

 

 

5. Piroctone Olamine — The Modern Scalp Hero

Piroctone Olamine is a newer, dermatologically preferred ingredient that’s changing the game in dandruff treatment. It effectively reduces the fungus Malassezia without irritating the scalp. It’s gentler than Zinc Pyrithione, less aggressive than Ketoconazole, and suitable for long-term use.

It also helps regulate scalp oil production, soothe inflammation, and maintain a healthy scalp microbiome—all without the harsh side effects of traditional treatments.

Pros: Antifungal, anti-inflammatory, gentle for daily use, prevents recurrence
 Cons: Less widely known to consumers
 Verdict: The most balanced and effective option for ongoing dandruff care

 

 

Where to Find It: Ivy & Lily – Ocean Breeze Dandruff Treatment Shampoo

Formulated with Piroctone Olamine, Ivy & Lily’s Ocean Breeze Dandruff Treatment Shampoo offers a refreshing and gentle solution for oily, dry, or sensitive scalps. It eliminates flakes, relieves itching, and leaves your hair soft and light.

This shampoo is perfect for daily use and is especially ideal for humid climates or those prone to scalp buildup.

Shop the product here:
 Ivy & Lily – Ocean Breeze Dandruff Treatment Shampoo

Back to blog